Jim Rogash - Getty Images
over 1 year ago: FOXBORO MA - NOVERMBER 21: Peyton Manning #18 of the Indianapolis Colts gestures against the New England Patriots at Gillette Stadium on November 21 2010 in Foxboro Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)
It seems the heat, specifically in the Twittersphere, that Bob Kravitz was taking after calling Peyton Manning's right arm a "noodle", was just a little too much for the Indy Star journalist.
On Friday, Kravitz did his best to clarify the comment, stating that he "misspoke":
"I do that sometimes on radio, especially when I haven't had my coffee. I was trying to be funny, flippant, basically saying you don't spend 35 million bucks on a quarterback with a noodle arm. In my head, I was thinking, 'He used to have a laser rocket arm, now it's closer to a noodle arm.' "
I can understand a harmless mistake and we've all had our fair share of bonehead comments. However, I think it's rather surprising that a respected journalist could use such a descriptive term (everyone knows what a friggin' "noodle arm" is...) only to later claim that he was basically messing around. Under these circumstances, that's not exactly a harmless mistake. We are kind of talking about a man's career here. So when you write in a town that currently has a ginormous media magnifying glass hovering above it, you really should try to practice some self-restraint and avoid such "funny" comments. Especially if they aren't, you know, totally accurate...

What seemingly makes the comment even worse is the fact that Kravitz was the first to be granted an exclusive interview by Manning post-surgery. And now this? Ouch.
Kravitz tried to further explain the reasoning behind his slip-up without making excuses, but kind of did anyway:
"In an effort to explain rather than make an excuse, when you do dozens and dozens of interviews over the course of two weeks (something I'm not used to doing), you occasionally say something you wish you hadn't said, or wish you'd said in a different way. I know that in the course of that same interview, I said that my sources said he was throwing 'OK,' but 'noodle arm' understandably has a way of catching people's attention."
I'll be the first to admit that I've personally never been a huge fan of Kravitz (I ride with Phil B.!). I do, however, respect his work as a journalist. If the content is there, you should be able to put your beef aside and enjoy the work. Kravitz has delivered some great pieces---the Manning exclusive was top-notch---and in a small way (as a fledgling journalism major myself), I have used his work, among others, as motivation to become a better writer.
But for a guy that's been in the game so long, this was an obvious no-no and now he's paying for it in the P.R. department.
Note to journalism self: Do not falsely claim that Peyton Manning's arm is a noodle.
0 recs | 44 comments
One good reason.....
Not to put stock in
everyany story that comes out by supposed people in the “know”. The only thing I know, is nobody fucking knows.tim55 - February 11, 2012
That's real wisdom there
Nobody knows
muncie_in_this - February 11, 2012 via Android app
noodle head
Bob kravitz has it. He’s not thinking straight.. Lol
kbreboot - February 11, 2012 via iPhone app
He is right about one thing
Kravitz is right about who has a noodle arm just the wrong person…it is he who has a noodle arm…and a noodle brain…..the guy just constantly causes issues with his false reporting and ridiculous comments…..I hope he gets fried on here and all over the media from this ridiculous statement….if I was editor of the Indy Star he would be fired long ago…
Colts53 - February 11, 2012
But the reality is -
Anyone who writes does these sorts of things. Or haven’t you read some of the stories on here in the past, that would rank up with Kravitz’ worst rants?
buymymonkey - February 11, 2012
Excellent point
Not to mention, unlike certain people who roam this website, he at least retracted…as opposed to dying on a given hill of stupidity. Which is the norm around here.
billp73 - February 11, 2012
in case its not obvious
he’s talking about Brad “Histrionics” Wells
BigBrueShoe - February 11, 2012 via Android app
Who is Bob Kravitz
If it were not for Peyton manning not many people outside of Indianapolis would know who Bob Kravitz is. He should show more respect for someone that put the colts and Indianapolis on the map(as far as football is concerned) and gave Kravitz something worthwhile to write about. I am a true colts fan and would write a lot differently than Kravitz does. If the Indy star needs a good sportswriter, email me about the position.
steve61 - February 11, 2012
that crashing sound you hear is Bonehead Bob backpedaling through the wall
Very little of bob’s writing I actually think is good, let alone respect. He’s more of an opinion as opposed to a journalist. I rarely agree with his opinion, and that’s fine, but it’s his style of writing and his inflammatory columns that are obviously meant to sell papers are what make me not respect him.
danorocks17 - February 11, 2012
BOB "NOODLE" KRAVITZ
enough said.
toolman94 - February 11, 2012
^^This^^
indylator - February 11, 2012
sure bob has heard the noodle comment from his wife a few times.
how this man still has a job as a indystar employee is crazy when i’ve read better articles on this blog and fans on here who didn’t go to a 4-year college. if he’s doing it to be funny or salacious then join TMZ.
BigMan74 - February 11, 2012
Time to pile on...
“Noodle arm” was the wrong way to characterize Mannings health whether right or wrong. Nevertheless, he is still very good at his job by serving as a polarizing figure for the newspaper. The newspaper is becoming more obsolete every day. If you pick it up to ready Kravitz, either because you typically agree with him or because you think he is an idiot, he has done his job. For me, his articles are usually the only reason to read the newspaper. I can get all other information that I need from the internet. In every market, someone needs to fill his position; taking a stance on hotly contested issues whether or not that stance is popular. Keep doing good work, Bob.
thomasezekiel77 - February 11, 2012
I see your point, but...
why retract your former statement? Stand by what you say, or be WAY more careful how you say it. That is what’s making him look silly.
(by “you” i mean Kravitz)
CoolJohnnieBNasty - February 11, 2012
This was deliberate...
Why did it take so long for him to publish a retraction? This was a cheap, deliberate attempt to garner attention. The guy is a joke of a journalist.
Antillar - February 11, 2012
Good grief
He said he had a noodle arm. If he can’t throw, HE HAS A NOODLE ARM!!!!!! Its not like he slapped his babies or something. That would be a reason for people to get upset!!! I will be so glad when this is over and Colts fans move on past Manning. The time to start over is now, whether Manning is healthy or not. This team had some foundational problems, most of which were fixed with the release of Polians/Caldwell. Mannings inflated salary/lack of talent around him can be fixed with his release and infusion of talented youth to the roster. Thank you for everything Manning but this is for the greater good of the TEAM. Unless your price comes down considerably, have fun with the Dolphins, Jets, Cardinals, 49ers or whoever else would consider signing you.
Dito29 - February 11, 2012
Give it up
Blueblocker - February 11, 2012
are you a kravitz also?
toolman94 - February 11, 2012
??
1. This comment is a joke.
2. This entire philosphy of rebuilding after 1 bad season (due to injury) seems to be one of the greatest overreactions in the history of sports.
3. If Manning is healthy by training camp, he must be the starter. Luck can sit the bench and wait his turn.
4. Instead of using Kravitz as your primary source of news on the subject, pay more attention to the actual NFL reporters who know what is going on. For example, this morning Mortensen explained that Manning is throwing the ball “very well” and will be ready to play at a high level again by the draft.
5. The greater good of the team is winning games and being a contender and Manning gives that….it has been proven time and time again.
For those who think that Luck is the 2nd coming of Christ (and I think he will be good but c’mon), he hasn’t even played a snap in the NFL yet. He is almost just as likely to be a complete bust as he is to be great. Statistics prove that with #1 picks as QBs.
AceOfSpades - February 11, 2012
Preach it brother !
Trade down, add more balance across the board, go to playoffs and win Super Bowl.
Rinse, repeat.
BoilerMacR - February 11, 2012
not going to happen
this isnt the movies
omahacolt - February 11, 2012
truth is stranger than fiction
BigBrueShoe - February 11, 2012 via Android app
awesome
any other irrelevant sayings you want to toss out there
omahacolt - February 11, 2012
Not a Luck issue it's a salary cap issue...
Unless Peyton is willing to play for much less the ride is over
(206)NightRidah - February 11, 2012 via mobile
OR
Keep Manning (if arm strength is good of course), and drop Freeney and his larger cap hit since they are moving primarily to a 3-4. Saves even more cap money and the team remains competitve.
AceOfSpades - February 12, 2012
i dont like that idea
freeney is our best player. dont want to see our best player shit canned
omahacolt - February 12, 2012
Wait...
You don’t want to cut Freeney cause he’s our ‘best player’, but judging from your comments you’re fine with Peyton being ‘shit canned’?
icedude - February 12, 2012
correct
omahacolt - February 12, 2012
A comment like this only warrants one response
coltsfan723 - February 12, 2012
not really
we are getting a new qb regardless.
omahacolt - February 12, 2012
He won't be the Colts' best player if at 75%
It’s gonna take much longer than 3 weeks for him to know what his ceiling will be…if he can’t play at 100% then he isn’t worth the money
If he can’t make all the throws…it would be a waste of cash to pay him! I don’t care how smart he is or what he did 5 years ago…Why pay someone top dollar to be 2/3 of what they are plus the inevitable physical regression people face after 35…
If he wants to do a cap friendly deal an work out hoping that he can get back that’s ideal…But I would expect Luck to refuse to come here if he could spend 3-4 years on the bench…so Irsay will have to choose…
I think anyone would take a 100% Manning for 4 years over Luck but since Mannings health is a question mark it would be best to cut Manning and build around Luck
(206)NightRidah - February 13, 2012 via mobile
I like this Stew Blake character!
nuff said
gujurarhti - February 11, 2012
kravvy is a writer first and foremost
so his written word is well thought out and what he is trained for. when we go to verbal, think on your feet stuff, it is not so much his element. i understand, dont blame him for the slip up, but hope he learns to be more careful in future.
Bluetime - February 11, 2012
This was obvious hyperbole
Google “noodle arm” and “quarterback”, jump enough pages to get past all the recent Kravitz quotes, and you’ll find a bunch of articles calling various NFL QBs or QB prospects “noodle arms” or “spaghetti arms.” It’s been around for a long time as a hyperbolic way of saying a QB doesn’t have great arm strength, not that the arm is literally as limp as a noodle. If Kravitz had used the term to describe a draft prospect or potential back-up who struggles with difficult throws, no one would have thought the term to be out of place. And that seems to be where Peyton is at right now – able to throw, but not make the tough passes that are expected from a superstar QB.
ex-Viking fan - February 11, 2012
this picture of peyton screams to me
“Kravitz, GTFO!”
danorocks17 - February 11, 2012
Big Picture
IMHO, I think Irsay wants Peyton to retire so badly that he is giving reports to the media that maybe not truth at all.
k1 - February 11, 2012
My thoughts exactly.
Irsay doesn’t want to man up and make a decision.
Manningonlyfan - February 11, 2012
Irsay may have already has made his decision....
Or he may still be thinking about it. Either way, Peyton is under contract to the Colts until March 8th. Season tickets renewals are due by March 1st. Irsay does not want to make his decision public until he has to.
thomasezekiel77 - February 12, 2012
Wow good point about ticket sales
Also there is no reason to rush this decision since Manning’s nerve regeneration and arm strength is a fluid, ongoing process. They should give it as much time as they can.
March 8 is well before the draft, so either way they will have a gameplan moving forward.
AceOfSpades - February 12, 2012
Yep which is why I don’t fault Manning too much if he were to play elsewhere if you want to get rid of him be a man and do it.
CF4L - February 13, 2012
He was man enought to pay him 25mil not to play
Peyton was paid and is under contract until 3/8 so Irsay owes him nothing
(206)NightRidah - February 13, 2012
Kravitz is an asshole
all the other writers are decent,, Mort reported he saw him throw and he had zip on the ball , I believe Mort before i believe Kravitz !!!!! And TOMORROW SUNDAY I will be rooting for my good friend KEN Duke to bring home his 1st PGA win 2nd- place 3 behind Wi, will be in the last group GO DUKEBOY I have a nice pick in my office of HIM and Peyton a few yrs ago at Pebble Beach from the tournament that year
OBGYNOSUPREME - February 11, 2012
He was probably thinking about Orton
SuperSerial - February 13, 2012
Note to journalism self: Do not falsely claim that Peyton Manning's arm is a noodle.
See, this is why journalists (no offense) suck.
We don’t really know about the status of Peyton Manning’s arm. If a professional journalist with historically ties to Peyton Manning says he can’t throw with NFL velocity, I’m inclined to believe that Peyton Manning’s arm is, in fact, a noodle.
I’m also inclined to to believe that Peyton Manning wants to play again, and Bob Kravitz wants to continue to get nice, one-on-one interview opportunities with Peyton Manning and other NFL stars. Hence what seems likely to me is
1. Kravitz told the truth as he believed it. In a tactless way.
2. He quickly realized, “oh shit”, telling the truth, especially tactlessly, is going to get me nowhere, so I better take that back if I want to keep my job, keep the interviews and access coming.
Simple as that. Journalists suck because they’re ostensibly supposed to go out an dig out the truth, but in practice they rarely do so, get in trouble for it, and more often act as PR for whomever they’re beholden to for access. Better journalists figure out how to report the truth while navigating these issues. Worse ones don’t bother trying.
Sports2 - February 13, 2012
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Stampede Blue to post a comment.